Streetwise
Lauren Rudd
Sunday, June 20,
2010
Consider These Pearls of Wisdom
If tax increases, the deficit, inflation and potentially
higher interest rates are clouding your investment horizon, cheer up, it could
be worse. For example, consider these pearls of economic wisdom.
Rand Paul, the Senate candidate from Kentucky who does not
support key provisions of the Civil Rights Act, is defending BP against
criticism from the Obama administration. Meanwhile his Dad, Ron Paul, a
Congressman from Texas, wants to abolish the Federal Reserve and return us to
the gold standard.
Sharron Angle, who will face off against Senate Majority
Leader Harry Reid, wants us out of the United Nations and would abolish the
Department of Education and the Internal Revenue Service.
Former Hewlett-Packard CEO Carly Fiorina uttered this
profound analysis of her opponent, Senator Boxer, “her hair is so yesterday.”
H-P’s share price fell 60 percent during Fiorina’s 5 1/2 year tenure as CEO,
while 3,000 employees lost their jobs and she received a $40 million golden
parachute.
So what does all this have to do with your investment
posture? A lot if you consider that supposedly rational (I use the term loosely)
politicians, or those hoping to become politicians, advocate eliminating the
Fed, the IRS, the Dept. of Education, placing us back on the gold standard and
getting everyone to a hair salon.
What is next, a reincarnated version of the Crusades, or
perhaps a rejuvenated Inquisition; or maybe we just cut to the quick and go
straight to hunting and gathering?
Suppose we concentrate instead on an in-your-face
energy-climate bill that actually reduces our dependence on fossil fuels and
deals with climate change. Add in enforced financial regulatory reform to
eliminate future economic calamity.
We need fiscal restraint but talk to the “small people” and
see if raising employment does not take precedence. Finally, we must ensure our
immigration policy attracts those who are productive while not denigrating us to
where we advocate a police state.
What we do not need is irresponsible fear-mongering that runs
the gauntlet from socialistic fantasizing to false fabrications about
imprisoning people for not having health care. To confound and obfuscate for
short-term political gain is not irresponsible, it is reprehensible.
Meanwhile, do not let fallacious political and economic myths
disrupt your search for new investments. For example, a possible candidate for
consideration is the Street’s latest casualty, Best Buy (BBY). Best Buy recently
posted lower than expected first-quarter numbers, hurt by rising costs to expand
its business and weaker consumer demand.
Actually, this was exactly the same story they told this time
last year. My earnings estimate back then was $2.90 per share and $3.30 per
share for FY 2011. Earnings for FY 2010 came in at $3.14 per share. My 12 month
price target on the shares a year ago was $40 per share. The shares recently
closed at $38.56, but only after dropping from $41 per share on June 15, as a
result of the latest quarterly report where the company posted first quarter
ended May 29 earnings of 36 cents per share, as compared with 36 cents per share
a year ago.
Probably what shocked the Street the most was that selling,
general and administrative (SG&A) expenses were 23 percent of revenue for the
quarter, up from 21.9 percent a year ago. The company said the increase was
driven by new stores, higher investments to raise sales and foreign currency
fluctuations. However, Best Buy also reiterated its earnings guidance for 2011
of $3.40 to $3.60 per share.
The intrinsic value of the shares using a discounted earnings model with an
earnings growth rate of 11.7 percent and a discount rate of 15 percent is $65
per share. The more conservative free cash flow to the firm model projects an
intrinsic value of $58. I am raising my earnings estimate for this fiscal year
to $3.55 per share with a 12 month target price on the shares of $44, for a 15
percent capital gain. There is also an indicated dividend yield of 1.40 percent.