Streetwise
Lauren Rudd
Sunday, February 22,
2009
Life Is Not Good, But It Is Not All That Bad
A year ago, I wrote that the world economy was slowing
rapidly, stock indexes were down 20 percent and that the loan and bond markets
were in disarray.
"The tax rebates will nicely complement the cuts the Federal
Reserve has made in the benchmark federal funds rate. It should enable us to get
through the correction," Secretary of Commerce Carlos Gutierrez predicted back
then. Well, we know how that movie ended.
The Treasury recently had to borrow $67 billion, issuing 3
and 10 year notes and 30 year bonds in what was the largest one week borrowing
event ever. At the same time, foreclosures in 2008 stood at 850,000 homes, with
1.2 million expected in 2009. For comparison purposes there are 76 million owner
occupied homes in the United States. Furthermore, the greed on Wall Street
resulted in 90 percent of those troublesome subprime mortgages being packaged
into bonds and sold to unsuspecting investors.
On a more positive note, the publicity surrounding potential
bank failures is overblown. In 2008, only 25 banks out of 8,384 actually failed;
or about 1 in every 335. During the 3.5 years following the Crash of 1929, 217
banks per month failed, equivalent to 7 per day.
Putting more people back to work is crucial to any economic
recovery program. While I still believe we face a possible double digit rate of
unemployment in 2009, given that 3.4 million people lost their jobs in 2008, the
good news is that 526,000 jobs were created in education and health services.
Both of those areas are destined to receive additional funding from the various
stimulus programs that will soon be underway.
Unfortunately, for many in Congress the realization that a
resurrection of the patently unsuccessful economic policies of the past makes no
sense continues to escape them. Instead of engaging in intelligent
bipartisanship activities, they resort to acrimonious outbursts and childish
behavior, such as dropping legislative documents on the floor in feigned
disgust. Immature conduct of that nature only serves to reflect poorly on the
electorate.
To the country’s credit, we now have a new quarterback,
playbook and offensive economic team. However, it took eight years to create the
current financial quagmire and the resurgence of economic activity will not
occur overnight. Rather, we should not expect to see tangible results until the
first quarter of 2010.
However, a well thought out investment strategy will enable
you to take advantage of the subsequent sharp rise in the equity markets that is
likely to occur as the various stimulus packages take hold.
One example of a company that may well add benefit to your
portfolio as the economy improves is Sherwin Williams (SHW). With many companies
cutting their dividend, Sherwin Williams recently announced an increase in their
quarterly dividend from $0.35 per common share to $0.355. Although the increase
was small, it added another notch to the company’s 30 consecutive years of
dividend increases.
For 2008, Sherwin Williams’ consolidated net sales were down
0.3 percent to $7.98 billion, resulting in a 14.9 percent reduction in net
income to $4.00 per share. Included in that income number were asset impairment
charges of $.31 per share. Net operating cash for 2008 was $864.4 million, or
10.8 percent of sales. At the same time the company issued 2009 earnings
guidance of $3.00 to $4.00 per share.
The intrinsic value of the shares using a discounted earnings model is $84,
assuming an earnings growth rate of 11 percent and a discount rate of 15
percent. The more conservative free cash flow to the firm model produced an
intrinsic value of $108 per share. My earnings estimate for 2009 is $3.80 per
share and $4.80 for 2010, with a projected 12 month share price of $50,
resulting in an 8 percent gain over the recent price of $46. In addition, there
is a 2.8 percent dividend yield.