Streetwise
Lauren Rudd
Sunday, January 11,
2009
There Are Opportunities Available
As I get ready to head to Las Vegas for this year’s Consumer
Electronics Show, the thought once again came to mind that it does not take much
in the way of ingenuity to postulate an association between Wall Street and
unbridled gambling. Furthermore, one might even conclude, taking recent events
at face value, that Wall Street had marked the cards and loaded the dice.
Although I will certainly acquiesce to the argument that the
fires of greed were fed by a regulatory environment that was far too lax,
remember that at one time many individuals were more than happy to “fudge” a bit
on a mortgage application, or gleefully speculate in a rising real estate
market, one that defied all reason and logic. Wall Street, in turn, did its part
to help sell the euphoria, while at the same time pocketing exorbitant fees. The
end result is all too evident in the carnage of decimated portfolios.
On a more positive note, I would counter that over time
equities will resume their rise in value as companies enhance their value
through dividends and retained earnings. A corollary to that theorem is that
there is no such thing as a market that does not have investment opportunities.
Moreover, market fluctuations should not enter into your
investment decision process. There has never been a time in history when there
were not reasonable investment opportunities available to those desirous of
searching for them.
Yes, the market’s overall 2008 performance was miserable.
That is certainly no secret. Unfortunately, market gains and losses do not
adhere to a desired or specific timetable. There are intervals, and we are
currently in one, where it could take two or three years before the worth of a
particular investment decision is fully vindicated.
That said; let us move on to looking for those investment
ideas that are going to be productive as we go forward into the coming year. To
illustrate the points just made, we will kick off our investment New Year with
Genentech (DNA).
A year ago my 2008 earnings estimate for Genentech was $3.75
and I had a target price on the shares of $81. Back then the shares were trading
at about $70. Genentech recently closed at $84 for an annual capital gain in
2008 of 26 percent. Yes, you read that correctly.
Founded more than 30 years ago, Genentech is a leading
biotechnology company that discovers, develops, manufactures and commercializes
medicines to treat patients with significant unmet medical needs. For the third
quarter ended Sept. 30, Genentech reported U.S. product sales of $2,452 million,
a 14 percent increase from the $2,155 million reported in the third quarter of
2007. Earnings per share came in at $0.68, a 6 percent increase from the $0.64
in the third quarter of 2007.
The company is currently forecasting full-year 2008 non-GAAP
earnings in the range of $3.40 to $3.45 per share, down from $3.40 to $3.50 per
share. The drop is due primarily to the cost of the employee retention programs,
estimated to be $0.08 per share in 2008.
It is interesting to note that the company’s cost of sales
fell to 15 percent of revenues in the third quarter, as compared to 17 percent a
year ago, while R&D expenditures increased to 22 percent of operating revenue,
as compared to 20 percent a year ago. Marketing, general and administrative
expenses came in at 18 percent of operating revenue, as compared to 19 percent a
year ago. In other words, the company spent less on overhead and put more money
into developing new products.
The intrinsic value of the shares using a discounted free cash flow to the firm
model with an earnings growth rate of 17 percent is $141 per share. Nonetheless,
I am going to lower my 2008 earnings estimate to $3.47 per share with an
estimate for 2009 of $4.25, and a 12-month target price on the shares of $97,
representing an annual gain of 15 percent.