Streetwise
Lauren Rudd
Sunday, May 4,
2008
Stocks Often Give You A Second Chance
Shortly after the Fed announced its most recent interest rate
reduction, the Dow Jones industrial average breached the 13,000 level for the
first time since last January. To many, Wall Street was finally on the path to
recovery. Unfortunately the euphoria evaporated as quickly as it came about,
proving once again that the wiles of Wall Street can be exasperating.
Even more gut wrenching is watching the price of a stock in
your portfolio cascade downward after clawing its way upward for one or more
years. Investing on Wall Street does call for some emotional fortitude. Yet, any
drop in the price of a stock translates to a potential buying opportunity.
Market performers, whose share price has fallen due to overall
market trends rather than a specific ailment within the company, often rise
again like the proverbial Phoenix. So if you were not fortunate enough to board
the train the first time, you may have another chance.
An excellent example is St. Jude Medical. St. Jude
manufactures and distributes cardiovascular medical devices. When I wrote about
the company a year ago, my earnings estimate for 2007 was $1.76 per share and
$2.10 for 2008. Reported GAAP net earnings for 2007 were $1.59 per share. If you
exclude one-time charges relating primarily to non-cash items, the adjusted
earnings were $1.85 per share. So did St. Jude meet my expectation and is the
adjusted number a better determinate of corporate performance.
Adjusted numbers are a two edged sword. If the charges are
truly one-time, and in particular are non-cash charges, then yes, the adjusted
number does give a more accurate portrayal of performance. The difficulty is
that too often companies use adjusted earnings as a way of hiding management
blunders. All of which means that you need to dig deeper. Adding to the strength
of St. Jude’s position is the increase in free cash flow for 2007, coming in at
$$1.64 per share, a five-year high water mark.
Moving ahead to the first quarter of 2008, St. Jude reported
net sales of $1.01 billion, an increase of 14 percent. Favorable foreign
currency translation comparisons increased first quarter sales by approximately
$45 million. This is another factor that should be discounted. Currency
translations are exogenous to the company and can work against it as well as for
it.
Net earnings for the first quarter of 2008 were $0.53 per
share. This compares favorably to the $0.41 per share posted a year ago. Passage
of the federal research and development tax credit would increase that to $0.54
per share.
St. Jude is in a highly competitive industry characterized by
short product life cycles and volatile fluctuations in market share. At the same
time, potential competitors face significant barriers due to the lengthy FDA
approval process and the major investments required in both R&D and
distribution. Meanwhile, St. Jude’s primary marketplace is expected to grow by
about seven percent in 2008, with St Jude likely to well exceed that growth
rate.
Revised Medicare reimbursement guidelines calling for an
approximate 3 percent reimbursement reduction, as compared an earlier proposal
for a cut of up to 23 percent, is also a positive development. For 2008, the
company’s gross margin will be approximately 74 percent, with SG&A expenses
consuming 36 percent of sales and R&D outlays representing about 12.5 percent.
The intrinsic value of the shares, using a discounted earnings approach, yields
a per share value of $50, while a discounted free cash flow to the firm model
suggests an intrinsic value of $63. The shares recently closed at $43.78. I am
raising my 2008 earnings estimate to $2.13 per share and $2.50 per share in
2009, with a 12 month target price of $49 per share, representing a gain of 12
percent. The company does not pay a dividend.